News Powerboats Sailing Industry Market Safety Electric Shows
Safety

Fishermen Sue U.S., Say Drones Sank Boat Ecuador's Navy Had Cleared

The crew of La Negra Francisca Duarte II filed an admiralty suit in Pittsburgh, saying drones from a U.S. vessel burned and sank their boat in March.

By Haye Kesteloo 5 min read

Fishing vessels moored at a quay under blue harbor cranes, beside a stone breakwater with a red and white light tower
Fishing boats at the quay in Manta, Ecuador, the home port of the crew that filed the suit, in October 2022. Photo: Gordon Leggett, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The crew of an Ecuadorian fishing boat that burned and sank in the eastern Pacific in March sued the United States on Monday in federal court in Pittsburgh. They say American drones set their boat on fire and American personnel then held them at gunpoint before handing them to El Salvador.

The boat, La Negra Francisca Duarte II, was one of three Ecuadorian fishing boats attacked near the Galápagos Islands this year, and no government has claimed responsibility for any of them, The Washington Post reported. According to the complaint, Ecuador’s navy had boarded the boat on its way home, inspected it for about three hours and cleared it to sail on, shortly before the drones arrived.

The Complaint Says Two Drones Hit the Boat 385 Nautical Miles Off Manta

Two armed drones attacked La Negra Francisca Duarte II on March 17, about 385 nautical miles (443 miles) off Manta and 225 to 235 nautical miles from San Cristóbal Island, according to the complaint. The crew had left Manta on March 2 and spent two weeks fishing off the Galápagos.

The complaint (which spells the boat’s name Francesca) says the fire set two crew members alight and burned their legs, arms and backs, one of them to the bone. All of the crew jumped into the sea, climbed into the small boats the fishing boat carried and headed for a blue ship in the distance while a surveillance drone followed them. The fire sank the boat, which the complaint says belonged to plaintiff Alejandro Hermógenes Flores Franco.

The Crew Says English-Speaking Sailors Hooded Them and Sent Them to El Salvador

The English-speaking sailors on the blue ship aimed rifles at the approaching crew, the complaint says. Some wore camouflage uniforms with U.S. flags, others life vests marked “US Coast Guard.” All but the most badly burned man were zip-tied, hooded and made to stand barefoot on a hot iron deck.

The complaint does not say which agency operated the ship. Each man got 500 milliliters (about 17 ounces) of water and no food, according to the filing, and personnel told the most badly burned crew member, through a translator, that they had fired the drones, showing him a drawing of the fishing boat on a blackboard. On March 18, the complaint says, the men were moved to a Salvadoran ship for a seven-day trip to El Salvador, where most were held at a care center for foreign migrants and the two burned men were taken to a hospital.

The Suit Treats the Drones as Part of a U.S. Vessel Under Admiralty Law

The fishermen sued under admiralty law, the body of law that covers collisions and other wrongs at sea. Their lawyer, Daniel Kovalik, argues that the Suits in Admiralty Act waives the government’s sovereign immunity, or failing that the Public Vessels Act, which covers damage caused by a U.S. public vessel.

The second route depends on the drones counting as part of a ship. The complaint cites a 2003 Eleventh Circuit decision for the point that an aircraft launched from a naval vessel to carry out the vessel’s mission is an appurtenance of that vessel, and a 1995 Supreme Court decision for the rule that damage caused by an appurtenance is treated as caused by the vessel. It states the factual premise in one sentence: “These drones were launched from a vessel operated by the United States.”

The suit, Flores Franco v. United States, No. 2:26-cv-02459, was filed November 16 and assigned to Judge Marilyn J. Horan the next day, according to the court docket. It brings four counts: intentional infliction of emotional distress, assault and battery, false imprisonment, and conversion of the boat. It asks for damages in an amount to be set at trial and an order ending U.S. attacks on boats in the Caribbean and the Pacific. The Washington Post reported the demand at $5 million; the complaint’s own text names no figure.

The Post Tied the Attacks to the CIA, While the Complaint Points to the Military

The Washington Post reported in August that the Galápagos attacks were part of a CIA covert action program. The complaint instead places the March 17 attack in the military campaign of strikes on small boats that began on September 2, 2025, and its only defendant is the United States.

It alleges that personnel under the command of President Donald Trump and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, acting in their official capacities, authorized or carried out the attack. It also says the government has publicly defended the boat strikes, including this one, as lawful, relying on a still-secret Justice Department legal opinion that treats them as part of an armed conflict with drug cartels. On November 14 the Post reported that a surveillance plane linked to the incidents was first owned by a company based in The Villages, Florida. U.S. Southern Command declined to comment on the suit, citing the pending litigation, and the Justice Department also declined, the Post reported.

The Post’s photographs of the three boats name them as the Fiorella, La Negra Francisca Duarte II and the Don Maca. The first attack, in January, left eight fishermen missing, as of the Post’s November 17 report, and the other boat attacked in March also sank.

Hullside’s Take

I think the fishermen picked the right body of law. Admiralty gives a foreign crew a way into a U.S. court over a lost boat, and it frames the case around a question maritime courts handle all the time, which is whose vessel did the damage. By the crew’s account their boat had just passed a navy inspection, and its owner lost the vessel the crew depended on. The Public Vessels Act route works only if a U.S. public vessel launched the drones. Neither the Post’s reporting nor the court file shows the government confirming which vessel or agency was involved, and Southern Command now cites the litigation as its reason to say nothing. The United States has 60 days from service to answer the suit or move to dismiss it, and that filing is the first time it has to say anything about this case on the record.

Sources: Flores Franco v. United States, No. 2:26-cv-02459 (W.D. Pa.), complaint filed November 16, 2026, and docket; The Washington Post.

Hullside uses automated tools to support research and source retrieval. All reporting and editorial perspectives are by Haye Kesteloo. Read our editorial standards or report a correction.

Hullside reports under its editorial standards. See a mistake? Corrections.

Keep reading

Boating news, every day.

Free. The stories that matter, and nothing else.